Hyvä vs Luma vs Porto: Which Magento 2 Theme Should You Use?
🎨 The Ultimate Magento 2 Theme Comparison
Choose the perfect theme for your Magento 2 store with our comprehensive comparison of the three most popular options: Luma, Porto, and Hyvä.
Introduction
Choosing the right Magento 2 theme is one of the most critical decisions for your online store. Your theme affects everything from page loading speed and user experience to conversion rates and SEO performance.
Today's comparison covers the three most popular Magento 2 theme options:
✅ Luma (Default Magento 2 theme)
Free, lightweight, developer-friendly
✅ Porto (Best-selling premium theme)
Feature-rich, ready-to-use designs
✅ Hyvä (Blazing-fast modern alternative)
Next-generation performance focus
This detailed guide compares their performance, features, pricing, and best use cases to help you make an informed decision.
1. Luma Theme (Default Magento 2 Theme)
📋 Overview
Type: Free, included with Magento 2
Best for: Basic setups, developers learning Magento
Technical Stack: LESS, jQuery, RequireJS
Support: Official Magento community
Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Lightweight & clean: Minimal bloat, fast initial load
- Good for customisation: Clean codebase for developers
- Free & officially supported: No licensing costs
- Stable foundation: Battle-tested across millions of stores
❌ Cons
- Limited design options: Basic styling out of the box
- Not optimised for speed: Uses older frontend technologies
- Outdated frontend tech: LESS, jQuery instead of modern alternatives
- Mobile experience: Responsive but not mobile-first optimised
When to Use Luma?
✔ You need a simple, free starter theme
Perfect for budget-conscious projects or MVPs
✔ You're a developer building a custom theme
Clean foundation without unnecessary bloat
✔ Learning Magento development
Best way to understand Magento's frontend architecture
✔ Need maximum extension compatibility
Works with virtually all Magento extensions
2. Porto Theme (Best-Selling Premium Theme)
🛒 Overview
Type: Premium (£99–£249)
Best for: Ready-to-use stores with rich features
Demos: 50+ pre-built industry layouts
Support: Professional theme support team
Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- 50+ pre-built demos: Fashion, electronics, furniture, etc.
- Drag-and-drop builder: Visual page construction
- SEO-optimised: Built with search engine best practices
- Rich features: AJAX cart, mega menus, quick view
- Regular updates: Active development and maintenance
❌ Cons
- Can be bloated: Slow if not properly optimised
- Expensive: Significant upfront investment
- Requires technical tuning: Performance optimisation needed
- Learning curve: Complex admin interface
- Customisation limitations: Can be difficult to modify deeply
When to Use Porto?
✔ You want a feature-rich, visually appealing store fast
Launch quickly with professional designs
✔ You need multiple layout options
Fashion, electronics, furniture industry templates
✔ Marketing-focused features are important
AJAX cart, product quick view, mega menus
✔ You have budget for premium themes
Can justify £99-£249 investment for faster development
3. Hyvä Theme (Next-Gen Performance)
⚡ Overview
Type: Paid (€1,500–€2,500 per year)
Best for: Stores needing maximum speed
Tech Stack: Tailwind CSS, Alpine.js, modern PHP
Performance: 3x faster than Luma
Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- 3x faster than Luma: Dramatically improved page speeds
- Modern tech stack: Tailwind CSS, Alpine.js
- No jQuery: Better performance and smaller bundle size
- SEO benefits: Faster loading improves search rankings
- Future-proof: Built with modern web standards
❌ Cons
- Not compatible with most extensions: Requires Hyvä-compatible versions
- Requires developer expertise: Steep learning curve
- Expensive: High annual subscription cost
- Limited ecosystem: Fewer available extensions and themes
- Migration complexity: Difficult to move from other themes
When to Use Hyvä?
✔ You need a blazing-fast Magento store
Performance is critical for SEO and conversions
✔ You're ready to invest in performance
Can justify high annual costs for speed benefits
✔ You have technical resources
Developers familiar with modern frontend tech
✔ Extension compatibility isn't a major concern
Can work with limited extension ecosystem
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Luma | Porto | Hyvä |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | £99–£249 | €1,500+/year |
| Speed | ⭐⭐ Slow | ⭐⭐⭐ Medium (with optimisations) | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Extremely fast |
| Customisation | High (requires coding) | Drag-and-drop builder | Developer-dependent |
| Extension Support | ✅ Full | ✅ Full | ❌ Limited |
| Learning Curve | ⭐⭐ Moderate | ⭐ Easy | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Steep |
| Best For | Developers, simple stores | Agencies, multi-niche stores | High-traffic stores |
Which Theme Should You Choose?
Choose Luma If:
- You're on a tight budget - Free foundation without licensing costs
- You need a basic, customisable foundation - Clean starting point for development
- Maximum extension compatibility is required - Works with virtually all Magento extensions
- You're learning Magento - Best way to understand the platform
Choose Porto If:
- You want pre-built designs for quick launch - 50+ industry-specific templates
- You need marketing-friendly features - AJAX cart, mega menus, quick view
- Visual page building is important - Drag-and-drop interface
- You have budget for premium themes - Can justify upfront investment
Choose Hyvä If:
- Speed is critical - SEO rankings, conversions depend on performance
- You have technical resources to manage it - Experienced developers available
- Future-proofing is important - Modern tech stack and practices
- Extension compatibility isn't a major concern - Limited ecosystem is acceptable
FAQs – Magento 2 Themes
1. Can I switch from Luma to Porto/Hyvä later?
✅ Yes, but it requires migration effort (especially for Hyvä).
- Luma to Porto: Relatively straightforward, mainly design changes
- Luma to Hyvä: Complete frontend rewrite, extension compatibility review needed
- Porto to Hyvä: Most complex migration due to different architectures
💡 Tip: Plan your theme choice carefully to avoid costly migrations later.
2. Is Hyvä worth the high cost?
✔ Yes, if:
- Your store suffers from slow loading times (affecting SEO and conversions)
- You're ready to replace incompatible extensions with Hyvä-compatible alternatives
- You have developers familiar with modern frontend technologies
- Performance directly impacts your revenue (high-traffic stores)
ROI Calculation: If 1% speed improvement = 1% conversion increase, Hyvä often pays for itself.
3. Does Porto work with Magento 2.4.7?
✅ Yes, but always check theme compatibility before upgrading.
- Porto regularly updates for new Magento versions
- Check ThemeForest product page for latest compatibility
- Test on staging environment before production upgrade
- Consider version lock until confirmed compatibility
4. How to optimise Porto for speed?
Essential optimisations:
- Enable Varnish Cache - Full page caching for faster load times
- Use Lazy Load for images - Reduces initial page load time
- Minify JS/CSS - Reduce file sizes and HTTP requests
- Optimise images - Use WebP format and appropriate compression
- Disable unused features - Remove unnecessary Porto modules
- Use a CDN - Serve static assets from edge locations
5. Can I use Hyvä with Page Builder?
❌ No, Hyvä replaces default frontend tech (including Page Builder).
- Hyvä uses its own content management approach
- Page Builder requires default Magento frontend stack
- Alternative: Hyvä-compatible page builders are in development
- Content can be managed through custom blocks and layouts
🔄 Workaround: Use headless CMS or custom content management solutions.
Conclusion
Your Magento 2 theme choice significantly impacts your store's success. Each option serves different needs:
- Luma is perfect for budget-conscious projects and custom development
- Porto excels for quick launches with rich, ready-to-use features
- Hyvä dominates when performance is critical and budget allows
Consider your budget, technical resources, performance requirements, and timeline when making your decision. Remember, the best theme is the one that aligns with your specific business needs and technical capabilities.
🚀 Need Help Choosing or Installing a Theme?
Get expert guidance on theme selection, installation, and optimisation. With 20+ years of Magento experience, I can help you choose and implement the perfect theme for your store.